Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

EVO Overspeeding During Spool-Up

Posted by kyosho 
EVO Overspeeding During Spool-Up
March 05, 2025 10:36AM
During spool-up, my EVO's governor seems to overspeed to around 2300 RPM before gradually settling at the requested 1800 RPM. The initial high headspeed sounds really scary. ???? This happens on both of my helis, even with different ESC brands.

Any ideas on what settings I should adjust to prevent this? Appreciate any insights! ????



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/05/2025 10:38AM by kyosho.
Re: EVO Overspeeding During Spool-Up
March 05, 2025 11:16AM
Hi,

no good style to answer questions with questions, but without more info, there's not much to work on ^^

Is this with or without blades?
Which ESC on which heli, with what setup (motor (kV), cell count, gear ratio)?
What mode is the respective ESC set to?
Default settings of the VBar Governor?

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Re: EVO Overspeeding During Spool-Up
March 05, 2025 12:08PM
Is this with or without blades? with blades
Which ESC on which heli, with what setup (motor (kV), cell count, gear ratio)? goblin RAW 500 6S and OMP M7 12S. gear ratio set according to manual.
What mode is the respective ESC set to? HW and xdfly
Default settings of the VBar Governor? both vbar gov
Re: EVO Overspeeding During Spool-Up
March 05, 2025 03:14PM
Hi,

well, to calculate the rpm window/approx. max. headspeed or governed, from battery full to empty, you'd go motor kV * cell count * cell voltage / gear ratio.
This should yield around 65 % throttle opening with full batteries, going higher as the battery voltage drops, to leave headroom for governing.

So,

(not provided) * 6 * 3.7 / (manual not provided) = (error)
(not provided) * 12 * 3.7 / (manual not provided) = (error)

A full calculation could be

450 * 12 * 3.7 / 9.63 = 2,075 rpm (at nominal voltage) or
450 * 12 * 4.2 / 9.63 = 2,355 rpm (at full battery)

With that, you could see if 1,800 is in the ballpark (guesstimated between 50 % throttle and up to 80 %, below is not good from a thermal perspective, higher is not good because there won't be enough headroom to govern when the battery is almost empty.).

On the other hand, what you can see/check is, the throttle bar on the main screen, does it also overshoot?
Or just rpm (on the display and/or audibly)?
Also see in Model Status/Governor?

If not, it'd be the ESC which is over-revving the motor, during spool-up, if, it'd be the VBar wanting more than required.

I'm not familiar with HW and XDfly, though, and their respective behavior and settings.
But with load, with blades, there's normally not much to to expect than a small rpm jump, if at all, _with default settings in the VBar and in the ESC, and _if_ the overall setup matches the rpm request.

For example timing and frequency settings in the ESC can also have an effect, normally auto works pretty well these days, otherwise auto/default timing and a low frequency (e.g. 12 kHz) are a good starting point.

Very many variables smiling smiley

Cheers

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login